A Comparative Insight into REIT Regulations: Egypt vs. Western Markets

This article presents an in-depth examination of the legal and regulatory landscape surrounding Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) in Egypt, emphasizing the associated opportunities, challenges, and future developments. The research assesses the current state of REITs in Egypt by scrutinizing pertinent legislation, including the Capital Markets Law and applicable tax regulations. It underscores critical compliance obligations and elucidates the organizational framework of REITs within the country. Furthermore, the article draws comparisons with established markets such as the United States and Europe, identifying best practices that could enhance Egypt's real estate investment climate. It also discusses the growth potential of the real estate sector, particularly through REITs, while addressing the obstacles these investment vehicles encounter, such as regulatory limitations, governance challenges, and tax implications. The article concludes with a series of recommendations, including tax incentives, streamlined regulatory processes, and legal reforms aimed at strengthening the position of REITs as a viable investment option in Egypt.
16 Dec, 2024
346 views
country flag
Dalila Djamane

Contracts Advisor Supervisor at Mountain View

Abstract

This article presents an in-depth examination of the legal and regulatory landscape surrounding Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) in Egypt, emphasizing the associated opportunities, challenges, and future developments. The research assesses the current state of REITs in Egypt by scrutinizing pertinent legislation, including the Capital Markets Law and applicable tax regulations. It underscores critical compliance obligations and elucidates the organizational framework of REITs within the country. Furthermore, the article draws comparisons with established markets such as the United States and Europe, identifying best practices that could enhance Egypt's real estate investment climate. It also discusses the growth potential of the real estate sector, particularly through REITs, while addressing the obstacles these investment vehicles encounter, such as regulatory limitations, governance challenges, and tax implications. The article concludes with a series of recommendations, including tax incentives, streamlined regulatory processes, and legal reforms aimed at strengthening the position of REITs as a viable investment option in Egypt.

Introduction

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) provide a mechanism for both institutional and individual investors to engage in the real estate sector without the necessity of direct property ownership. This investment structure enables the aggregation of capital from multiple investors to finance income-generating real estate assets, subsequently distributing dividends to shareholders derived from the profits accrued. The advantages associated with REITs encompass diversification, enhanced liquidity, and the potential for consistent income streams. Although REITs have been a staple in Western economies for many years, their introduction in Egypt has been relatively recent. The US Congress established the legal framework for REITs in 1960 [1], leading to the launch of the first REIT on the New York Stock Exchange five years later. Subsequently, REITs made their way into Europe through the Netherlands in 1969, followed by Australia in 1971 and Canada in 1993, and they are now prevalent in numerous global markets.

In recent years, Egypt's economy has experienced substantial growth, particularly within the real estate and construction sectors, largely due to government initiatives aimed at developing new cities and infrastructure. However, despite these advancements, the utilization of REITs within the Egyptian real estate market remains limited. This article seeks to evaluate the current legal and regulatory landscape governing REITs in Egypt, while also identifying the opportunities and challenges that these investment vehicles encounter in their quest for growth and effectiveness.

1. Current State of REITs in Egypt

1.1 Overview of REITs in Egypt

Real estate investment funds have emerged as a prominent financial instrument within the real estate sector, gaining significant traction in numerous countries globally. These funds have established themselves as a vital investment avenue for both individuals and corporations seeking substantial financial returns from real estate ventures.

In Egypt, the utilization of real estate funds has recently gained force, with a growing number of real estate and financial firms striving to introduce a variety of investment funds tailored to the demands of investors. Among the most notable funds currently available in the Egyptian market are:

  • Egypt Real Estate Investment Fund 1

Egypt Real Estate Investment Fund 1 is the latest real estate investment fund established in Egypt. It was established in cooperation between Banque du Caire, Misr Insurance Holding Company and Allianz Insurance Company. The fund aims to invest in commercial assets with periodic returns.

One of the most important features of the fund is that it provides the opportunity to achieve good returns for investors, and it also works to distribute risks on the properties owned by the fund. Egypt Real Estate Investment Fund 1 is part of a series of real estate investment funds that Banque du Caire intends to launch during the coming period.

The bank targets a capital of EGP 500 million for the fund, which was approved by the Financial Regulatory Authority, and the first issue of the fund was subscribed to at about EGP 360 million through a group of local and foreign financial institutions [2].

  • Egypt Sovereign Fund

Egypt Sovereign Fund works to develop untapped assets and resources, by concluding partnerships with the private sector with the aim of achieving sustainable development goals through safe investment for future generations.

The Egypt Sovereign Fund allows for huge investment partnerships on a group of unused assets, by supporting the government's role in implementing structural reforms, which inevitably leads to increased economic growth in all sectors [3]. The Sovereign Fund has a number of branches, which are:
- Egypt Sub-Fund for Financial Services and Digital Transformation.
- Egypt Sub-Fund for Utilities and Infrastructure.
- Egypt Sub-Fund for Health Services and Pharmaceutical Industries.
- Egypt Sub-Fund for Tourism, Real Estate Investment and Antiquities Development.

1.2 Legal Structure and Regulatory Environment

The Capital Markets Law No. 95 of 1992 and its subsequent amendments, which regulate the operations of capital markets, including real estate investment vehicles, govern REITs in Egypt. REITs were formally introduced in Egypt by Decision No. 34 of 2014 and its amendments [4], but their uptake has been limited. As of now, there are very few active REITs in Egypt, and their market capitalization remains small compared to other emerging and developed markets.

Real Estate Finance Law (Law No. 148 of 2001): Since the real estate investment funds can involve the jurisprudence of mortgages, understanding this law is necessary for investors.

The Egyptian Financial Regulatory Authority (FRA) is responsible for regulating REITs, ensuring that they comply with the legal framework and adhere to investor protection standards. However, the regulatory environment in Egypt has posed certain challenges, which have limited the growth and appeal of REITs. These challenges include complex compliance requirements, an uncompetitive tax structure, and limited public awareness of REITs as an investment option.

REITs in Egypt must comply with several key legal requirements. Under the Capital Markets Law, REITs must not exceed 95% of the fund’s total assets in income-generating real estate such as residential, commercial and hospitality properties. This restriction ensures that REITs focus on stable and profitable investments, reducing their exposure to high-risk ventures such as investing in early-stage companies that have high growth potential but also significant risks or investing in technological innovations that rely on new or untested technologies.

Additionally, REITs in Egypt are subject to strict reporting and compliance standards. They must submit quarterly financial reports to (FRA) and carry out regular audits to ensure transparency and accountability. Although these measures are essential to investor protection, they can also increase the administrative burden on REITs, particularly for smaller companies that may lack the resources to meet these requirements.

1.3 Tax Implications

One of the significant barriers to the growth of REITs in Egypt is the tax treatment of these investment vehicles. Unlike in many other jurisdictions where REITs enjoy favourable tax treatment, Egyptian REITs are subject to corporate income tax 22.5% at the standard rate [5]. This reduces their profitability and makes them less attractive to investors, particularly compared to other investment options.

In addition, there are no specific tax incentives for individual or institutional investors in Egyptian REITs. This lack of tax advantages has limited the appeal of REITs as an investment vehicle, particularly for foreign investors who may be subject to double taxation on their returns.

2. Comparative Analysis with Mature Markets

2.1 The United States

The United States is home to one of the most developed and successful REIT markets in the world. In 2021, the total economic impact of US REITs and associated enterprises was approximately 3.2 million full-time equivalent (FTE) positions [6]. REITs were first introduced in the U.S. in 1960 through the Real Estate Investment Trust Act, and they have since become a popular investment vehicle for both institutional and retail investors [7]. There are several key features of the U.S. REIT market that have contributed to its success:

Tax-Exempt Status: U.S. REITs benefit from tax-exempt status at the corporate level, provided they distribute at least 90% of their taxable income to shareholders in the form of dividends. This tax advantage has made REITs a highly attractive option for investors seeking steady income streams [8].

Liquidity: U.S. REITs are publicly traded on major stock exchanges, providing investors with the ability to buy and sell shares with ease. This liquidity is one of the key advantages of REITs over direct property investment, which can be illiquid and difficult to exit.

Diversification: U.S. REITs offer exposure to a wide range of real estate sectors, including residential, commercial, industrial, and healthcare. This diversification allows investors to spread their risk across different asset classes.

Egypt could benefit from adopting similar practices to the U.S. model, particularly in terms of providing tax incentives to REITs and their investors. The introduction of favourable tax treatment, such as the exemption of REITs from corporate income tax, would make these investment vehicles more attractive and could stimulate growth in the sector.

2.2 Europe

REITs have also gained traction in Europe, where countries like the United Kingdom and France have developed robust legal frameworks to support their growth. In these markets, REITs operate under a tax-efficient structure and are subject to stringent governance standards. Key features of European REIT markets include:

Harmonised Tax Treatment: In many European countries, REITs benefit from a harmonised tax treatment that reduces or eliminates corporate taxes on the condition that a large percentage of profits are distributed to shareholders. This creates a more level playing field for REITs compared to other investment vehicles [9].

Governance Frameworks: European REITs are required to adhere to high standards of corporate governance, with a clear separation between the roles of fund managers and property managers. This helps to reduce conflicts of interest and ensures that the interests of investors are prioritised.

Egypt can draw from these examples to improve its own REIT governance structures. Strengthening governance frameworks in Egypt could help to build investor confidence and attract more capital into the REIT market.

2.3 Global Comparative Analysis of REIT Market Capitalization in 2023

The comparative analysis of market capitalization trends in Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) between the US, Asia and Europe in 2023 reveals significant differences in growth trajectories and market maturity. In the US, the REIT market has experienced substantial expansion, driven by favorable regulations, investor appetite for diversified income streams, and a robust real estate sector.

In contrast, Asian and European REITs have faced more stringent regulatory frameworks and varying degrees of market acceptance across different countries. However, recent years have shown a growing recognition of REITs in Europe, leading to increased market capitalization and investment interest [10]. This analysis highlights how macroeconomic factors, regulatory environments, and cultural perceptions of real estate investment have shaped the distinct paths of REIT market development in these two regions [11].

3. Opportunities for Growth in Egypt’s Real Estate Sector through REITs

3.1 Population Growth and Urbanisation

Egypt is the most populous country in the Arab world, with a rapidly growing population that has fuelled demand for housing and infrastructure. This presents a significant opportunity for REITs to play a role in financing real estate projects, particularly in the residential and commercial sectors. With urbanisation on the rise, there is an increasing need for new housing developments, office spaces, retail centres, and industrial parks.

REITs offer a mechanism for pooling capital from domestic and foreign investors to finance large-scale real estate projects. By channelling investment into income-generating properties, REITs can contribute to meeting the growing demand for real estate while providing investors with steady returns.

3.2 Government-Led Infrastructure Projects

The Egyptian government has embarked on an ambitious programme of infrastructure development, which includes the construction of new cities, transport networks, and public facilities. The development of the New Administrative Capital, for example, is one of the largest real estate projects in the region. REITs could play a crucial role in financing such projects, allowing both domestic and international investors to participate in Egypt’s economic growth.

By investing in infrastructure projects through REITs, investors could benefit from stable and long-term income streams, while the government could leverage private capital to fund its development agenda.

3.3 Potential for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)

Egypt’s strategic location, coupled with its large and growing real estate market, makes it an attractive destination for foreign direct investment (FDI). REITs can serve as a vehicle for attracting foreign investors who are looking for exposure to Egypt’s real estate sector but are deterred by the complexities of direct property ownership. By offering a regulated and transparent investment structure, REITs can facilitate FDI into Egypt’s real estate market, contributing to economic growth and job creation.

4 Challenges Faced by REITs in Egypt

4.1 Governance and Investor Protection

One of the main challenges facing REITs in Egypt is the lack of a robust governance framework. Although REITs are regulated by the (FRA), there are still concerns about the separation of roles between fund managers and property managers. This can create conflicts of interest and undermine investor confidence in the market.

4.2 Tax Structure

As discussed, the current tax structure in Egypt does not offer significant advantages for REITs. The corporate tax imposed on REITs, coupled with the lack of a pass-through taxation system, makes them less attractive compared to REITs in other jurisdictions.

4.3 Regulatory Complexities

The complex regulatory framework can be an obstacle for REIT formation and operation. While The Egyptian Financial Regulatory Authority (FRA) plays an important role in maintaining transparency and protecting investors, its stringent requirements can act as a deterrent for smaller investors or startups looking to enter the market.

5. Recommendations

  • Tax Reforms

To attract more investment into REITs, Egypt should consider implementing tax reforms similar to those in the U.S. and Europe. Introducing a pass-through taxation system, where REITs are not subject to corporate tax if they distribute a significant portion of their profits to investors, would greatly enhance their appeal. Additionally, tax incentives for foreign investors could make Egyptian REITs more competitive on the global stage.

  • Strengthening Governance

Reinforcing governance practices by clearly defining the roles and responsibilities of property managers and fund managers would reduce conflicts of interest and improve investor confidence. Introducing more stringent shareholder protection laws, including voting rights and dispute resolution mechanisms, would further enhance transparency and trust in the market.

  • Simplifying Regulatory Requirements

To encourage the establishment of REITs, the regulatory process should be simplified. Reducing the administrative burden on REIT operators, especially smaller entities, would allow for greater participation in the market. Streamlined regulations could focus on ensuring compliance while offering flexibility for innovative real estate projects.

  • Public Awareness and Education

Promoting public awareness of REITs as an investment vehicle is crucial for the growth of the market. Educational campaigns and workshops targeting both retail and institutional investors would help demystify REITs and encourage broader participation.

Conclusion

Real Estate Investment Trusts offer immense potential to transform Egypt’s real estate market, attracting both local and foreign investment. However, for REITs to reach their full potential, significant legal and regulatory reforms are needed. By implementing tax reforms, strengthening governance, and simplifying regulations, Egypt can create a robust framework that positions REITs as a leading investment vehicle. The future of REITs in Egypt appears promising, but it will require coordinated efforts between regulators, industry players, and investors to overcome existing challenges.

References:

  1. Anna Mazurczak, 'Development of Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) Regimes in Europe' (2011) 4(1) Journal of International Studies 115-123.
  2. 'Banking & Insurance Alliance Launches Egypt Real Estate Investment Fund 1’ Invest-Gate (25 October 2024) <https://invest-gate.me/news/banking-insurance-alliance-launches-egypt-real-estate-investment-fund-1/> accessed 25 October 2024.
  3. The Sovereign Fund of Egypt, ‘Multi-Sector Investment’ <https://tsfe.com/ar/multi-sector.html>accessed 25 October 2024.
  4. Financial Regulatory Authority of Egypt, Decision No 34 of 2014.
  5. PwC, 'Egypt - Corporate Taxes on Corporate Income' (PwC Tax Summaries) <https://taxsummaries.pwc.com/egypt/corporate/taxes-on-corporate-income> accessed 25 October 2024.
  6. EY, 'REIT Economic Contributions to US Economy' <https://www.ey.com/en_us/insights/real-estate-hospitality-construction/reit-economic-contributions-to-us-economy> accessed 25 October 2024.
  7. US Government, Cigar Excise Tax Extension of 1960.
  8. US Securities and Exchange Commission, 'Investor Bulletin: Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs)' (SEC, Page 1).
  9. Hans Op’t Veld, The Impact of European REITs: The Role of Real Estate Investment Trusts in the European Economy (Amsterdam School of Real Estate ASRE, Research Paper).
  10. Statista, ‘Market Capitalization of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) in the United States from 1975 to 2022’ <https://www.statista.com/statistics/916665/market-cap-reits-usa/> accessed 25 October 2024.
  11. EPRA, EPRA Total Markets Table - Q4 2023 <https://prodapp.epra.com/media/EPRA_Total_Markets_Table_-_Q4-2023_1706014781134.pdf> accessed 25 October 2024.
Latest Articles

Aksa Bethel Linson Aksa Bethel Linson

UAE’s New Competition Law: A Game-Changer in Market Regulation

The UAE has taken a bold step toward encouraging fair competition and enhancing regulatory enforcement by implementing Federal Decree-Law No. 36 of 2023, which ...

13 Feb, 2025
Ahmed Elnaggar Ahmed Elnaggar Indira Turdiyeva Indira Turdiyeva

ADGM Temporary Work Permits

In today’s business landscape, people are the asset. If you have the right ones, you win, and if you have the wrong ones, you lose. And if the right ones ...

11 Feb, 2025
Raluca Gatina Raluca Gatina

100 Wills, 100 Stories: Protecting Legacies in the UAE

As a legal professional with over a decade of experience in succession planning, I've had the privilege of drafting more than 100 wills for clients across the U...

24 Jan, 2025
View All
Newsletter

Sign Up!

Stay updated with the latest legal news, events, and expert insights from The Jurist.

By subscribing, I agree to receive newsletters and promotional content from the Jurist. I also agree to the Terms of Use and have read the Privacy Statement. No Thanks.
Newsletter Signup

Get the latest news and exclusive insights.